The delicate balance between hope and acceptance becomes even more crucial when we or a loved one faces end-of-life. Hospice care emphasizes comfort and dignity over curative treatment. However, a new phenomenon, toxic positivity, has emerged, potentially jeopardizing the well-being of hospice patients. This raises a critical question: Could an excess of optimism be harmful to hospice patients?
To understand this, we must delve into the mindset of terminally ill patients. Facing mortality is an emotionally turbulent journey filled with uncertainties and fears. While positivity can provide solace and strength, excessive optimism may distort perceptions and cloud judgment. Patients with progressive diseases usually grapple with many emotions, ranging from sadness to anger and fear. Unrealistic optimism may overlook these valid feelings, dismissing them as obstacles to be overcome rather than acknowledging them as part of the human experience.
Optimism as a Reason for Hope
Positivity undoubtedly plays a crucial role in coping with cancer, Alzheimer’s, and other terminal illnesses. Even on the verge of challenging circumstances, a pleasant attitude boosts resilience, fosters hope, and enhances overall well-being. However, it can become detrimental when positivity deviates into thoughts of denial or avoidance. Terminally optimistic patients may cling to unrealistic expectations, withholding opportunities for honest conversations about their prognosis and end-of-life preferences.
Honesty is the core principle within hospice care. It entails open and candid discussions about the patient’s condition, prognosis, and treatment options. The prevalence of unhealthy positivity can complicate these conversations. Patients may feel pressured to maintain a mask of positivity, fearing that expressing their genuine emotions could be perceived as weakness or negativity.
Quitting Hospice is Every Patient’s Right, But Is It a Good Choice?
Excessive optimism may lead patients to pursue aggressive or experimental treatments that offer little chance of meaningful improvement. Early-stage clinical trials, while promising in some cases, may not be appropriate for hospice patients whose primary goal is to maximize comfort and quality of life. By chasing unrealistic hopes, patients may inadvertently sacrifice precious time that could be well spent with loved ones, engaged in many activities that could bring them joy and fulfillment.
When making decisions together, it is best to use a patient-centered approach. First, it is paramount to carefully think about why a patient may not accept the prognosis. They or their loved ones may still have not come to terms with the idea of dying. It is essential to use good communication skills to share information in a way that patients are more likely to accept. Also, a surrogate decision-maker’s involvement could be necessary when needed.
The Risks of Eternal Positive Thinking
These days, there is considerable societal pressure to maintain a positive outlook. Some people consider positivity a form of wellness treatment and advise against embracing negativity. However, enforced optimism disregards the harsh realities of our existence. Some patients believe that negativity will shorten their lives, but researchers have conclusively found that optimism does not impact the survival of terminally ill patients.
In fact, encouraging patients to be positive may even add to their burden. Regardless of whether one is ill or not, the notion that everything must remain positive is not always sustainable. It must be balanced with realism. Anticipating that outcomes will always be favorable can lead to disappointment and anxiety, as we cannot ensure these outcomes will occur.
Some patients have even expressed that discussing worst-case scenarios with their loved ones and health providers has been practical and reassuring. Acknowledging the possibility that things may not work out well can significantly reduce fear over time.
Hospice is a Place for Comfort
The issue of unrealistic optimism extends beyond the individual level to systemic challenges in end-of-life care. Healthcare providers face ethical dilemmas in balancing hope with honesty. While it is okay to instill optimism while providing support, it is equally crucial to convey accurate information and manage expectations realistically. This approach requires a subtle strategy that acknowledges the complexity of the human experience and respects the autonomy and independence of patients in making informed decisions about their care.
So, is being optimistic inherently bad for hospice patients? Not necessarily. Optimism can be a source of strength and resilience when tempered with realism and acceptance. When optimism becomes detached from reality and inhibits honest thought and decision-making, it can be detrimental to the well-being of terminally ill patients.
At Ascend Hospice Care, we prioritize honesty and acceptance while providing positive and proper support to our patients and their loved ones. Therefore, we must facilitate an environment that embraces hope and realism, empowering patients to go through their end-of-life journey with dignity and autonomy.
